|
|
Once again, we take pleasure in delivering to your mailbox the April issue of The Elder Law Report, a monthly e-newsletter full of the latest legal developments and other trends of vital interest to seniors and their advocates.
As always, we welcome your comments and questions. You may send them to Info@ElderLawAssociates.com. Please indicate if we can include your question in our Reader Questions & Comments column. |
|
Retirement Home Resident Fights Move to Increased Level of Care
An 88-year-old California widow is challenging an attempt by her continuing care retirement community (CCRC) to move her from her private apartment to an assisted living unit. If she is successful, the outcome could set a legal precedent for more than 5 million Americans living in retirement communities, CCRCs, and assisted living facilities.
In 1991, Sally Herriot and her husband, John, paid a $180,000 non-refundable entrance fee to Channing House, a Palo Alto CCRC that offers residents a continuum of care, from independent living to skilled nursing units. As is typical of CCRC contracts, the Herriot's admission agreement gave Channing House's administrators the right to determine the appropriate level of care for the couple and the authority to move either of them into an assisted living unit or a skilled nursing facility if and when it determined they needed more care.
Mr. Herriot died in 2005. Last year, Channing House notified Mrs. Herriot -- who uses a walker, needs help getting dressed and has problems with her eyes -- of their intention to move her from her spacious ninth-floor apartment with a covered balcony to a much smaller, hospital-like assisted-living unit where she would share a room but also be served by a trained nursing staff. Mrs. Herriot resisted, saying that with the help of the round-the-clock private aides she hires herself, she has everything she needs and does not require a higher level of care.
Mrs. Herriot's attorneys, Michael Allen and Susan Silverstein (who is with AARP), filed a lawsuit alleging that by forcing Mrs. Herriot to move, Channing House is violating anti-discrimination housing and disability laws. Channing House's executive director, Carl Braginsky, counters that decisions to move residents from one level of care to another are made only after careful consideration and consultation with medical staff. Paul Gordon, one of Channing House's attorneys, rejected as "insulting and misleading" Mrs. Herriot's attorneys' assertions that such decisions are motivated by the opportunity for financial gain, such as from the sale of Mrs. Herriot's now greatly-appreciated apartment.
The result of the case could have lasting repercussions on how America's burgeoning population of seniors is allowed to age. "If Sally Herriot can be forced to move, then it undermines the whole concept of aging in place," her attorney Michael Allen told the San Francisco Chronicle. "A favorable outcome in this case might ... help someone with dementia or other more severe disabilities in a similar setting."
Lawyers on both sides are scheduled to begin mediation in April, and considering that CCRCs are in the business of marketing peace of mind, Channing House may have additional incentives to avoid a trial. If a trial becomes necessary, Mrs. Herriot is prepared. "I'm a fighter," she says. "I'm sure they think I should shut up ... I'll put something in their way every time they move."
To read the San Francisco Chronicle account of the dispute, click here.
For more information on retirement living, assisted living facilities and continuing care retirement communities (CCRCs) click here.
|
States Go After Living Trust Scams
On March 7, 2007, Minnesota's attorney general became the third attorney general to file suit against two California companies, American Family Legal Plan (AFLP) and Heritage Marketing and Insurance Services, run by the same family that allegedly sold inappropriate living trusts and annuities to seniors. Last year, state attorneys general in Pennsylvania and North Carolina filed suit against the same companies.
According to the lawsuits, American Family Legal Plan (AFLP) and Heritage Marketing and Insurance Services, both run by a father and son from California, convinced seniors they were receiving impartial investment advice when in reality the companies were pushing their own products. The lawsuits allege that sales agents convinced seniors to purchase living trusts that were not necessarily in their best interest and were not tailored to their individual needs. After consumers agreed to purchase the living trust plans, the sales agents allegedly persuaded them to exchange or convert their investments for annuities, even if the annuity would have a negative financial impact or tax consequence.
In one case, an 85-year-old Pennsylvania man was allegedly sold a 10-year deferred annuity with his first payout not coming until he turned 95. In North Carolina, according to the attorney general's charges, a sales agent convinced a couple in their seventies to cancel an insurance policy, cash in their investments, and put all of their savings into an annuity that he promised would earn 7 percent interest. The agent didn't tell them the interest rate was guaranteed for only one year and they would face steep penalties if they needed to withdraw their money. Another North Carolina woman cashed in an IRA to purchase an annuity after the sales agent allegedly told her the IRA would run out of money in five years. He allegedly didn't tell her that the annuity would cut her monthly income from $1,700 to less than $300.
In recent years, companies running these so-called "trust mills" have been targeted in many states. In 2005, the Ohio Supreme Court fined a Nevada-based seller of living trusts for engaging in the unlawful practice of law. The company supposedly targeted senior citizens in Ohio regardless of whether the customer actually needed a living trust or an estate plan. In addition, California shut down one company providing misleading investment advice in 2004 and filed a lawsuit against another company in 2005.
There are a number of steps you can take to avoid getting scammed, including avoiding high-pressure sales tactics and high-speed sales pitches, not trusting companies that say the AARP is selling or endorsing their product, and making sure a living trust is properly funded. For more on how to avoid living trust scams, click here. In addition, to help older adults and families make better decisions about annuities, the Healthcare and Elder Law Programs Corporation (H.E.L.P.) has created a Web site, annuitytruth.org. The site features H.E.L.P.'s new seven-part "Special Report: Annuities and Older Adults," as well as a list of federal and state agency contacts for making complaints if a person has been sold an annuity in unsuitable circumstances.
For more on the Minnesota suit, click here.
|
| Review: How to Protect Your Family's Assets from Devastating Nursing Home Costs: Medicaid Secrets
K. Gabriel Heiser. Phylius Press, Superior, Colo., 2007.
233 pages. ($47.00 - Click on book to order).
Nursing home costs are expensive and keep going up. While not presuming to take the place of an attorney, this book provides information on qualifying for Medicaid to pay long-term care costs, giving readers a broad overview and ideas to bring to their attorneys.
Author K. Gabriel Heiser, an attorney specializing in elder care and estate planning, provides detailed and practical information on how Medicaid works and the strategies for qualifying for it. Very up-to-date, Medicaid Secrets includes the recent changes to Medicaid transfer rules made by the Deficit Reduction Act of 2005. Heiser takes a complicated subject and presents it in an easy to understand manner. Medicaid law varies from state to state, so the strategies won't work in all states, but the book gives readers a broad overview and many ideas to bring to their attorneys.
The book begins by explaining what Medicaid's coverage of long-term care is and how to apply. The author provides detailed information on the income and asset qualification rules for both single and married individuals. The book then goes into strategies to qualify for Medicaid, including converting assets from countable to non-countable resources, making transfers to family members, entering into a personal services contract, using annuities, and changing a will in case a spouse ever needs nursing home care. There is also detailed information on estate recovery and several case studies. As the law changes frequently, the author's web site will provide updates to the law and corrections to the book.
|
Why Plan Your Estate?
No one likes to dwell on the prospect of his or her own death, but if you postpone planning for your demise until it is too late, you run the risk that your intended beneficiaries -- those you love the most -- may not receive what you would want them to receive.
This is why estate planning is so important, no matter how small your estate may be. It allows you, while you are still living, to ensure that your property will go to the people you want, in the way you want, and when you want. It permits you to save as much as possible on taxes, court costs and attorneys' fees; and it affords the comfort that your loved ones can mourn your loss without being simultaneously burdened with unnecessary red tape and financial confusion.
All estate plans should include, at minimum, two important estate planning instruments: a durable power of attorney and a will. The first is for managing your property during your life, in case you are ever unable to do so yourself. The second is for the management and distribution of your property after death. In addition, more and more, Americans also are using revocable (or "living") trusts to avoid probate and to manage their estates both during their lives and after they're gone.
For more on estate planning, click here.
| |
|
|
Elder Law Associates PA is a boutique elder law firm that practices exclusively in Medicaid and long term care planning; home and community-based waiver services; Medicaid applications; nursing home residents' rights litigation; asset preservation planning with a special focus on planning in light of the Deficit Reduction Act of 2005, including promissory notes and personal care agreements; disability planning, including special needs trusts and guardianship; estate planning, including wills and trusts; long term care insurance; advanced directives; and probate, which encompasses estate and trust administration. We assist clients in planning for the possibility of disability, incapacity, home health care, assisted living and/or nursing home placement. Our firm enables clients to avoid impoverishment caused by the escalating cost of long term care, to maintain their right to make health care decisions and to avoid unnecessary medical treatment.
We hope you have enjoyed The Elder Law Report. If you have questions about something you read, elder law matters or issues concerning persons with disabilities, we would be delighted to hear from you. We serve as an elder law resource to many professionals and organizations and want to become your elder law resource as well. You can reach us at Info@ElderLawAssociates.com.
Feel free to share The Elder Law Report with others who will benefit from our insights - just click on the blue "Forward email" link at the very bottom of the page.
Warm regards,
|
Ellen S. Morris, Esq. & Howard S. Krooks, Esq., CELA
Elder Law Associates PA
phone: (561) 750-3850 / (800) 353-3752
fax: (561) 750-4069
This publication is intended for general information purposes only. It is not intended to constitute individual legal advice to any specific client. |
|
|